Mantle Horizontal Header Logo

Exploring Contrast: Color vs Black and White Traditional Tattoos

Important Note:

More often than not, what you may see as a “black and white” tattoo is technically referred to as a black and grey tattoo because the combination of black and grey ink is used more frequently in tattooing than black and white.

Whether you’re considering a traditional tattoo in black and white or color, we recommend getting a full scope of tattoo styles available to you by reading our article breaking down tattoo styles.

black and white traditional tattoos

The Basics of American Traditional Tattoos

We’ve all seen or heard about traditional tattoos. That iconic, old-school style that feels like it should be gracing the arm of a rugged sailor. But what exactly are these traditional tattoos, and what sets them apart from other tattoo styles

Traditional tattoos, also called “American traditional tattoos” or “old school tattoos”, emerged in the late 19th and early 20th century. They’re characterized by stark and robust line work, a limited color palette, and iconic design elements, such as roses, anchors, and skulls, to name a few. 

This style was designed to be functional and enduring. Since tattoos would often degrade over time for sailors due to external elements like the sun and water, traditional tattoos were created to withstand these effects, maintaining their strong, vibrant essence for as long as possible. However, a new wave has shifted in recent years, leading to the growing popularity of black and white traditional tattoos

For great examples of traditional and other styles, we recommend you check out our work and our Instagram.

What Makes Black and White Traditional Tattoos Unique? 

As opposed to their colorful counterparts, black and white traditional tattoos are known for their stark contrast and timeless class. By using varying shades of black and grey, these tattoos allow for a depth and intensity that can completely transform traditional designs. This monochromatic palette highlights the strength of the line work, one of the key elements in traditional tattoos. 

Aesthetic Differences

While black and white traditional tattoos and colored traditional tattoos use the same thematic elements and techniques, the biggest distinction lies in their aesthetic. 

Black and white traditional tattoos offer a subtle but powerful depth with bold, black outlines and high-contrast, grey shading. This maintains the classic and iconic appearance of American traditional tattoos while creating more focus on the image itself. Often, black and white traditional tattoos can have a more dramatic feel and fit the general growing trend of black and grey tattoo themes. 

On the other hand, color plays a distinctive role in American traditional tattoos, introducing vibrant reds, blues, greens, and yellows to the traditional color palette. The addition of these bright hues enhances the visual impact of those familiar nautical motifs. Colorful American traditional tattoos often evoke a sense of nostalgia while adding a lively and dynamic quality to the overall design.

mantle tattoo_los angeles_traditional tattoo_achor


Longevity plays a key role when it comes to choosing between color and black and white traditional tattoos. After all, the tattoo you ink today is meant to be a lifelong piece of art that accompanies you forever. 

Black and white traditional tattoos often withstand the test of time better than their colored counterparts. Some colors naturally fade faster than others, likely because of the way they reflect light. For example, pastel colors are most likely to fade quickly and, on the other side of the spectrum, black ink has the longest lifespan.

The longevity and vibrance of the tattoo’s color palette largely depend on several factors like the quality of ink used, exposure to sunlight, and the individual’s skin type. (There’s no getting around it, black ink looks best on a wider variety of skin tones than many colors do.) However, despite colors fading, they can still offer an eye-catching display of artistry. 

Note: No matter if you opt for a black and white traditional tattoo or a colored one, proper tattoo aftercare is essential to preserve its appearance. Regular moisturizing, protection from harsh sunlight, and routine touch-ups can drastically improve the longevity of your tattoo.

How do you get proper aftercare advice? Well, you should talk to your artist. Looking for a tattoo shop full of artists that know what they’re doing? Go ahead and read our reviews, then schedule a consultation with us.

The Artistic Appeal of Black and White Traditional Tattoos

Black and white traditional tattoos possess a timeless grace and complexity – a unique blend of simplicity and sophistication that speaks volumes. 

mantle tattoo_los angeles_traditional tattoo_black and grey daggers

Even though these designs lack the color that can often make traditional tattoos exciting, it’s this literal black-and-white perspective that encourages creativity in shading and texture. The use of grey shading and black lines in this style lends them an air of enduring strength and elegance, creating a distinctive contrast not often found in their colored counterparts. 

Whether a tattoo is adorned with rainbow hues or comprises only shades of grey, what truly matters is the person wearing it and the meaning it holds for them. That’s where black and white traditional tattoos come into their own; they allow the story to shine through, undisturbed by sometimes extraneous color. 

  • Shading: One of the finest aspects of a black and white traditional tattoo is the shading. By playing around with black, grey, white,  and even negative space on your skin, the best artists can manipulate the focus and emphasize certain elements of the design. 
  • Texture: Traditional tattoos don’t always have significant textural elements because of the 2D nature of the style but if you do encounter it, some texture in a black and white traditional tattoo can create illusions of depth and dimension.
  • Contrast: Stark contrasts can lead to bold dramatic effects. The use of contrast can also help some elements stand out and others recede, thereby adding a level of visual interest to the tattoo.

How Color Schemes Impact the Meaning of Traditional Tattoos

Color schemes can significantly influence the meaning and aesthetics of traditional tattoos. Tattoo artists worldwide have used colors to draw symbolism and bring depth to their designs no matter what style they use.

mantle tattoo_los angeles_traditional tattoo_eagle black and grey
mantle tattoo_los angeles_traditional tattoo_eagle

American traditional tattoos have certain rules that make the style what it is, and one of them is the color palette. Traditional tattoos rely on bold shades of basic colors: red, yellow, blue, and green. (Compare this to neo traditional tattoos with the same style of line work but a more extensive line of colors available.) These colors help this style stand the test of time and sun exposure. You can’t help tattoos from fading but this style ensures you’ll have something bright and enduring. 

As of the last decade or so, there is a growing trend showing a strong move towards black and grey tattoos whether they’re traditional or not. This monochrome style adds a certain depth and intensity that colored tattoos can sometimes struggle to achieve. 

The essence of a black and white traditional tattoo lies in its simplistic charm. These tattoos are typically characterized by bold black outlines filled in with solid black ink, stark shading, and the occasional use of white to create highlight and contrast – a technique likely inspired by classic art and printmaking. 

  • Symbolism: While colors in traditional tattoos often bring out specific meanings and convey emotions, black and white traditional tattoos express depth, seriousness, and timeless elegance. Many believe that these tattoos carry powerful, personal, and introspective meanings.
  • Aesthetics: The aesthetics of black and white traditional tattoos are distinctive. They allow for intense contrast and a strong visual impact. The gradation of blacks, greys, and whites can create impressive dimension and depth that can be more striking than their colored counterparts.
  • Versatility: The black and white traditional tattoo style is versatile and universally flattering on all skin tones. It’s less about the range of colors and more about the design’s shape, symbolism, and shading.

Color definitely plays a vital role in traditional tattoos, but the shift towards black and white traditional tattoos is not just a passing trend. It has much to do with their timeless appeal, deeper symbolism, and distinct aesthetics. Whether you are captivated by the colored past of traditional tattoos or you find yourself drawn to the black and white designs, the choice of color scheme or lack thereof, ties directly into the overall meaning and impact of these traditional body arts.

Questions so far? Contact us.

Exploring the Evolution: From Color to Black and White Traditional Tattoos

If you look over the history of tattoos, it’s fascinating to observe how the art form has evolved over centuries. Tattooing, as an art form, echoes the preferences, culture, society, and technology of different time periods. 

So, what sparked the move to black and white traditional tattoos? The shift is intimately tied to societal evolution as we gain technological advancements and change our perceptions of art. 

black and white traditional tattoo lady
  1. Technological advancements: Over time, newer methods of crafting tattoos led to advancements in black ink. This made it easier for artists to create highly detailed, intricate designs that were more prominent in black and white.
  2. Changing perceptions of art: Changes in artistic trends also influenced this shift. People began to see the beauty in simplicity and minimalism, prompting appreciation for black and grey tattoos due to their sharpness, contrast, and depth.

In the context of black and white traditional tattoos, “less is more” seems to be the inspiring mantra. These tattoos, free from the distractions of color, focus more on design, contrast, and meaning. The lines appear more prominent and the depth perceivable, making these tattoos a captivating and rich visual experience. 

Why Black and White Traditional Tattoos Are Standing the Test of Time

What stands out about black and white traditional tattoos? One cannot deny the significant aesthetic appeal that these monochromatic pieces hold. The simplicity creates striking designs that remain timeless. 

Firstly, black and white traditional tattoos have a remarkable way of communicating the beauty and intricacy of the style. Stripped of the distraction of color, the lines, shading, and intricate details of the tattoo take center stage. This focuses on the ‘bare bones’ of the design.

Not to mention, black and white traditional tattoos acquire an aged and vintage look over time, adding to their character and charm. Much like how an old photograph holds a sense of nostalgia.

The versatility of the traditional style is unrivaled. 

  • Timeless Aesthetic: Black-and-white tattoos often exude a timeless and classic aesthetic that transcends trends. The simplicity of greyscale allows for a straightforward and enduring appeal.
  • High Contrast and Clarity: Monochrome tattoos rely on strong contrasts between black ink and skin, enhancing the clarity of the design. This can result in a bold and easily readable tattoo that maintains its visual impact over time.
  • Age Gracefully: Black-and-white ink tends to age more gracefully than colored ink. Over the years, color tattoos may fade or change, while well-executed black-and-white tattoos can maintain their integrity and visibility.
traditional flowers tattoo

Lastly, the art of tattooing is anchored in traditional techniques – techniques that originated in a time long before color inks flooded the market. Black ink has been used in tattooing for thousands of years and will always carry that classic charm. 

The Role of Color in Traditional Tattoos

Color plays an instrumental role in weaving the narrative of any traditional tattoo design by complimenting the robust linework that often defines these tattoos. 

It’s a crucial element in American traditional tattooing, contributing to the style’s distinctiveness, symbolism, and enduring popularity. The vibrant and bold use of color enhances the visual storytelling of traditional motifs.

american traditional tattoo los angeles
  • Vibrancy and Boldness: American traditional tattoos are known for their vibrant and bold color palette. Reds, blues, greens, and yellows are commonly used to create eye-catching and lively designs. The boldness of these colors enhances the visual impact of the tattoo, making it easily recognizable.
  • Nostalgia and Tradition: The tradition of using a specific color palette in American traditional tattoos creates a sense of nostalgia. The style harkens back to the early to mid-20th century, evoking a bygone era of tattoo artistry. Colorful tattoos in this style contribute to the preservation of traditional tattooing heritage.
  • Enhanced Symbolism: Beyond the traditional motifs, the choice of colors can add layers of symbolism to the tattoo. For example, a red rose might signify love and passion, while a blue anchor could represent stability and strength. This interplay of color and symbolism enriches the storytelling aspect of the tattoo.

However, the increasing emergence of black and white traditional tattoos is challenging the reliance on color in traditional tattoo design. Black and white tattoos appeal to simplicity and natural design contrast, delivering an aesthetic that captures the attention without reliance on complex color schemes. 

The true beauty of black and white traditional tattoos resides in their ability to emphasize form and texture over color. The black and white scheme uses the power of highlights and shadows to bring your image to life no matter the tattoo placement

While the role of color in traditional tattoos provides a visual spectacle, the understated elegance of black and white traditional tattoos offers its own unique lure. They have an inherently timeless appeal, contrasting the passing fashion trends that colored designs sometimes follow. 

Mantle Tattoo DTLA

Looking for a place that can give you a quality black and grey traditional tattoo? You found us. Schedule a consultation with us to talk about your ideas and let us bring your tattoo to life. 

Not ready to take the plunge? Check out our work or follow us on Instagram!

Mantle Tattoo Los Angeles

Related Topics

Unraveling the Skill and Intricate Art of Realism Tattoos

Unraveling the Skill and Intricate Art of Realism Tattoos

In the diverse landscape of tattoo art, realism emerges as a captivating genre that transcends traditional boundaries. These tattoos, renowned for vivid depictions of lifelike portraits and objects, showcase the expertise of artists who seamlessly blend creativity...